AM Aesthetics Journal  ·  Treatment Guide

Polynucleotides Under Eyes vs Tear Trough Filler: Which Fixes Your Dark Circles?

Practitioner in pink gloves supporting a woman's face as she lies back on a clinic treatment bed

Table of Contents

Quick answer: Polynucleotides and tear trough filler treat different causes of dark circles. Polynucleotides are a course of injections that aim to improve thin, crepey or discoloured under-eye skin over several weeks. Tear trough filler adds volume to a hollow groove under the eye and works straight away. If your dark circles are mainly shadow from hollowing, filler is usually the more direct tool. If the skin itself is thin, lined or pigmented, polynucleotides are often the better first step.

Key takeaways

  • Dark circles have more than one cause, and the cause decides the treatment. Pigmentation, visible blood vessels and hollowing all look “dark”, but respond differently.
  • Polynucleotides work gradually over a course of sessions. In a 2026 real-world study of 61 patients, a three-session course reduced dark circle severity, with the strongest effect in hollowing-type circles.
  • Tear trough filler gives an instant change but carries specific risks around the eye, including a bluish tint and persistent swelling that can appear long after treatment.
  • Some people are not good candidates for filler at all. Puffy lower eyelids and fluid-prone skin are the classic examples.

Under-eye treatment is one of the fastest-moving areas in UK aesthetics. In UK Google searches, “polynucleotides under eyes” now sits in the same 10,000 to 100,000 monthly search bracket as “tear trough filler”. Yet most of the advice online treats them as rival products, as if you simply pick the newer one. That framing misses the point. They do different jobs, and choosing the wrong one is the most common reason people feel an under-eye treatment “didn’t work”.

What actually causes dark circles?

Dark circles are multifactorial. A 2026 study of polynucleotides for periorbital darkness lists age-related changes in the midface, sun exposure, anaemia and hormonal factors among the contributors, and groups dark circles into three broad types that clinicians use in practice:

Type What it looks like What is going on
Structural (hollowing) A groove or shadow between the lower eyelid and cheek, worse under overhead light Loss of support and volume, so the area falls into shadow
Pigmented Brown or grey-brown colour that does not change much with lighting Extra pigment in the skin
Vascular Blue, purple or pinkish tone, often more visible when tired Thin skin letting underlying blood vessels show through

Most people have a mix. The useful question in a consultation is: which of these is doing most of the damage on your face? A simple test is to look in a mirror under a single overhead light and then tilt your face up towards the light. If the darkness largely disappears when you tilt up, shadow from hollowing is a big part of it. If the colour stays, pigment or vessels are playing a bigger role.

Mature woman looking at the camera with natural under-eye skin texture and fine lines visible
Most dark circles combine hollowing, pigment and thin skin in different proportions. (Illustrative image: Pexels)

What are polynucleotides, and what can they do under the eyes?

Polynucleotides (PN) are purified DNA fragments sourced from fish, typically salmon or trout, delivered as an injectable gel. They do not add volume the way filler does. Instead, they are used to improve the quality of the skin itself: thickness, texture, crepiness and tone. That is why they suit the under-eye area, where the skin is among the thinnest on the body.

The evidence is growing but still early. Two 2026 studies are the most relevant for under-eye treatment:

  • Dark circles: a real-world study of 61 patients across five countries, including the UK, used three sessions of a 7.5 mg/mL polynucleotide gel, given two to three weeks apart. Dark circle severity scores fell significantly by three months after the last session. The structural (hollowing) group showed the clearest improvement, the pigmented group also improved, and there were too few vascular cases to draw conclusions.
  • Under-eye lines: a prospective study of 42 patients treated with two sessions three weeks apart found patient-rated lower eyelid appearance improved substantially, peaking at three months and easing slightly by six months.

Neither study had a control group, and the dark circle study was supported by the device manufacturer, so treat the results as encouraging rather than definitive.

What to expect from a polynucleotide course

In those studies, side effects were mild and short-lived: some swelling, redness or minor bruising, usually settling within hours to a couple of days. In the dark circle study, 34% of patients had a mild reaction such as swelling or redness, and nearly all resolved the same day. Because the product is derived from fish DNA, a fish allergy is a reason not to have it. The trade-off is time: results build gradually across a course of sessions rather than appearing on the day.

What does tear trough filler do, and what are the risks?

Tear trough filler is a hyaluronic acid gel placed under the eye to fill the groove where the lower eyelid meets the cheek. When hollowing is the main cause of the darkness, it can make a striking difference immediately, because it removes the shadow.

What most people miss is that the under-eye area is one of the least forgiving places to put filler. The specific risks are well documented:

  • Persistent swelling (malar oedema): filler along the tear trough can cause swelling in up to 11% of cases, according to the American Academy of Ophthalmology’s EyeWiki, and it can appear long after treatment. Too much product, or the wrong type placed too superficially, raises the risk.
  • Bluish discoloration (the Tyndall effect): filler placed too close to the surface can show through thin skin as a blue-grey tinge, which can look worse than the original circle.
  • Vascular events: rare, but serious. Blocking a blood vessel with filler is the most serious complication of any filler treatment.

The safety net is that hyaluronic acid filler can be dissolved with an enzyme called hyaluronidase, which requires a prescription in the UK. A practitioner who places tear trough filler should be able to access it and explain how they would manage a complication.

Polynucleotides vs tear trough filler: side-by-side

Polynucleotides Tear trough filler
Best for Thin, crepey, lined or discoloured under-eye skin A visible hollow or groove casting a shadow
How it works Improves skin quality over time Adds volume to the hollow
When you see results Gradually, over weeks, after a course Immediately, once swelling settles
Typical course Usually two to three sessions, a few weeks apart Usually a single appointment, sometimes with a review
Main risks Mild, short-lived swelling, redness or bruising Persistent swelling, bluish tint, lumps, rare vascular events
Reversible? Not applicable; it does not create volume Yes, hyaluronic acid filler can be dissolved
Not suitable if You have a fish allergy You have puffy lower lids or fluid-prone swelling
Practitioner in a clinic treating the face of a woman lying on a treatment bed
The under-eye area needs careful assessment before any injectable. (Illustrative image: Pexels)

How to decide which one you need

In practice, the decision comes down to four questions, and a good practitioner should work through them with you:

  1. Is there a real hollow? If tilting your face up to the light makes most of the darkness vanish, volume loss is driving it, and filler is on the table.
  2. What is the skin like? Thin, crepey or finely lined skin is where polynucleotides earn their place, and it also makes filler more likely to show.
  3. Do you swell easily? Morning puffiness, fluid bags or a history of swelling after treatments are reasons to be very cautious with tear trough filler.
  4. How patient are you? Filler is immediate. Polynucleotides ask for a course and a few weeks of waiting.

Some people need both. When that is the case, improving skin quality first can mean any later filler decision is smaller and more conservative. And for some faces, neither is the right answer: puffy lower lids, for example, may be better served by other approaches altogether.

Under-eye treatment at AM Aesthetics London

At AM Aesthetics London we offer both polynucleotides for the under-eye area and tear trough dermal filler (from £350), alongside other under-eye treatments such as PRP, PRF and mesotherapy-based lightening. Having all of these available means the recommendation can follow the cause of your dark circles rather than the treatment we happen to sell.

If you are also weighing up skin quality treatments more broadly, read our guide to polynucleotides vs skin boosters.

Not sure which under-eye treatment suits you? Call us on 0741 369 6979 or message us on WhatsApp 07376 767645. Ready to go ahead? Book a Treatment.

Common questions

Do polynucleotides get rid of dark circles?

They can reduce them, particularly when thin skin or mild hollowing is the main cause. In a 2026 real-world study of 61 patients, a course of three under-eye polynucleotide sessions significantly reduced dark circle severity three months after treatment, with the clearest improvement in hollowing-type circles and a smaller improvement in pigmented circles. The study had no control group, so results vary. Polynucleotides will not fill a deep groove the way filler can.

How many polynucleotide sessions do I need for under eyes?

Most published protocols use a course rather than a single session. The 2026 studies used two or three sessions spaced two to three weeks apart, with results assessed one to three months after the final session. Your practitioner will tailor the number of sessions to your skin, and some people choose occasional maintenance sessions afterwards.

Is tear trough filler safe?

It can be when the patient is well selected and the injector is experienced, but it carries specific risks. These include persistent swelling, which affects up to 11% of tear trough cases according to the American Academy of Ophthalmology’s EyeWiki, a bluish tint if filler sits too superficially, lumps, and rare but serious vascular events. Hyaluronic acid filler can be dissolved with hyaluronidase if needed.

Can I have polynucleotides and tear trough filler together?

Some people benefit from both, because they address different problems: skin quality and volume. Whether they are combined, and in which order, should be decided after an assessment of your under-eye area. Improving the skin first can sometimes reduce the amount of filler needed later.

Who should not have under-eye polynucleotides?

Because polynucleotides are made from fish DNA, anyone with a fish allergy should avoid them. Studies have also excluded people who are pregnant or breastfeeding, those with an active infection in the area, and people with recent treatments in the same area. Share your full medical history at your consultation.

Sources

About the author: Anita Morris is the Founder and Lead Aesthetic Practitioner at AM Aesthetics London and founder of the AM Aesthetics London Academy. She holds an MSc in Aesthetic Medicine and has more than 20 years’ experience in aesthetics. This article is general information and is not a substitute for a personal consultation.